johnny9fingers: (Default)
Slightly hung-over at breakfast this morning whereupon reading my newspaper I stumbled across this rather good review of James Shapiro's new book Contested Will: Who Wrote Shakespeare.

Given that the various Oxfordian theories are going to get a new airing with the development of Roland Emmerich's movie Anonymous, I can understand some folk needing to get their rebuttals in early.

Nothing pleases like 400 year old conspiracy theories. It shows just how these things carry through the ages: and whenever they are newly uncovered, they infect new generations. One might almost think that such schema had a life of their own, replicating the debate across the centuries. It's almost like politics.
johnny9fingers: (Default)
This is bizarre.
My Interweb connection falls over, then picks up again, then falls over again.
Oh well.

I have been thinking a lot about 'Opposed Pairs' in language.
You know:

Black - White
Good - Bad
Left - Right
Up - Down

The reason I've been pondering such is a debate on Patriotism that my chum [profile] readwriteblue instigated on the [community profile] politicartoons page.
Now [profile] readwriteblue (fortune favour him in his tasks) is serving his country in Afghanistan at present, and posted a set of cartoons in the run up to the public holiday on Monday which dealt with Patriotism: and to my shame, not realising the nature of the American holiday, I equivocated and quoted Dr Johnson.

As an aside, in Blighty, our Rememberance Day is the 11th of November (The 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month, the time the WWI armistice was signed and ratified).

The reason I quoted the good doctor is because of the nature of opposed pairs: if someone claims an exclusive use of, let us say, 'Good', it renders those not in agreement  'Bad'.
If someone uses the word Patriot one looks for its opposite: which tends to be...traitor.

Now, I realise this wasn't what [info]readwriteblue meant (however, with me such realisation often dawns slowly) but it has been in the nature of a number of the arguments from others that one side embracing Patriotism leaves the other side traitorous: and this is often used to disguise the wrongness inherent in a position.

I still think the good Doctor has much to say about patriotism that we can all learn from.
But I should never forget those who are prepared to serve their country, and risk life and limb in their country's cause.

Henry V. Act IV Scene I

    Ay, or more than we should seek after; for we know
    enough, if we know we are the king's subjects: if
    his cause be wrong, our obedience to the king wipes
    the crime of it out of us. 

Which sums up what all servicemen believe, else they could not serve.
Honour to them, but beware of your Kings, even if elected.

Profile

johnny9fingers: (Default)
johnny9fingers

June 2021

S M T W T F S
  12345
6789 101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930   

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated May. 29th, 2025 03:08 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios